Search court decisions

…AND STEPHEN MBUKI KIMANI ..................................RESPONDENT R U L I N G Having heard advocates for both parties and in all the circumstances of the case, I am satisfied that this is a proper case to exercise my discretion…

…The court has a wide discretion in this matter.…

…But this discretion, howsoever wide it may be, is a discretion to be exercised judicially having regard to the particular circumstances of each case.…

…This was a matter within the discretion of the Judge and unless we feel that he had gone completely overboard, we would not substitute his discretion with ours even if we felt we could have reached a different decision.…

…his discretion in the appellant’s favour.…

…An application under Rule 4 of the Rules seeks this Court’s exercise of its unfettered discretion. In SAMKEN LIMITED, ABERCROMBIE & KENT LIMITED VS.…

…Though the discretion is unfettered, like all judicial discretion, it must be exercised on reason, not caprice, and the exercise must not be arbitrary or oppressive.…

…Now that the discretion is a free one the only question is whether, on the facts of this case, that discretion should be exercised in favour of the applicant.…

…In my judgment the applicant has not shown in this case that he should have the unfettered discretion exercised in his favour.…

…In the exercise of his discretion to enlarge time on such terms as may seem just to him, the learned single judge disallowed the application.…

…from the case as a whole that he was clearly wrong in the exercise of his discretion and that as a result there has been injustice.…

…Ngugi, however, strongly urged that the discretion under rule 4 is unfettered. This is true. But like all discretion it must be judicially exercised.…

…Here, there is no material before me on which I can base an exercise of my discretion in favour of the applicant.…

…As I set out to exercise my discretion I must at the outset confess that there is no material before me on which I can do so. As was said by Privy Council in RATNAM V.…

…In my judgment, once there is non-compliance the burden is on the party seeking indulgence to satisfy the court why the discretion should nevertheless be exercised in his favour.…

…We are of course aware that we ought not to interfere with the exercise of discretion by a judge or substitute our own discretion instead.…

…We have to be careful when differing with a judge who has exercised his undoubted discretion not to set aside an ex-parte judgment.…

…As regards the exercise of that discretion, certain principles are now well established in our law.…

…This is a matter for the discretion of the court and there is enough material here on which it could be found that the magistrate had exercised his discretion correctly. Order IXB rule 3.…

…We were pressed to consider whether the judge has arrived at such a wrong decision that this court should upset the exercise of the unfettered discretion of the judge.…

…Plainly, the judge misapprehended sub-rule (2) of the rule 10 in the exercise of his discretion and as a result reached a wrong conclusion.…

…“The discretion is in terms unconditional. The courts however have laid down for themselves rules to guide them in the normal exercise of their discretion.…

…Whether on the material presented to him the judge should have set the judgment aside and reopened the matter, was entirely for his discretion. The learned judge exercised that discretion against the appellant.…

…I now turn to consider whether I should exercise my discretion, under rule 4 of the Rules, to grant the application.…

…The starting point is, as it must be, rule 4 itself which confers the widest measure of discretion and makes no distinction between the various classes of cases.But like all discretion, it must be exercised judicially.…

…Before us, the applicant complains that the learned judge was wrong in the manner in which he exercised his discretion but in our view the application before the judge and the one before us are frivolous.…

…The learned judge was not obliged to consider any other grounds the applicant may have had for seeking exercise of that court's discretion when he came to the view that the applicant was less than candid.…

…Since the grant of the injunction is discretionary this court would not normally interfere with the exercise of that discretion.…

…The circumstances in which this court will disturb the exercise of a discretion of a trial judge were stated by the Court of Appeal for East Africa, in the case of MBOGO –VSSHAH (1968) E.A. 93.…

…The point for decision in this appeal is whether the learned judge was right in refusing to exercise his discretion to allow the amendments sought.…

…I also agree with what Lord Griffths said in the Ketteman Case (supra) at page 62: "Whether an amendment should be granted is a matter for the discretion of the trial judge and he should be guided in the exercise of the discretion…

…Mwamu, for the respondent, is whether a mistake of law by counsel can amount to such a mistake as would entitle the Court to exercise its unfettered discretion under rule 4 and extend time on behalf of an applicant such as…

…, this statement is to be found at page 94: “the mistake or misunderstanding of the plaintiff’s legal adviser, even though negligent, may be accepted as a proper ground for granting relief under Order IX rule 20 ….. the discretion…

…It is evident from the reading of this provision that the Court enjoys a wide measure of discretion on the question of interest.…

…The only ground argued in this appeal is an objection to the learned trial judge’s exercise of discretion in awarding interest on the decretal amount.…

…This Court held that notwithstanding the trial judge’s wide discretion in the matter: “….it is impossible to ascertain the reasons which compelled the judge to award interest from the date of filing suit and this leads us…

…to the inevitable conclusion that the learned judge wrongly exercised his discretion” We have in the present appeal, an analogous situation where we cannot ascertain the reasons which compelled the learned judge, without…