Search court decisions

…We are of course aware that we ought not to interfere with the exercise of discretion by a judge or substitute our own discretion instead.…

…We have to be careful when differing with a judge who has exercised his undoubted discretion not to set aside an ex-parte judgment.…

…The point for decision in this appeal is whether the learned judge was right in refusing to exercise his discretion to allow the amendments sought.…

…I also agree with what Lord Griffths said in the Ketteman Case (supra) at page 62: "Whether an amendment should be granted is a matter for the discretion of the trial judge and he should be guided in the exercise of the discretion…

…This Court held that notwithstanding the trial judge’s wide discretion in the matter: “….it is impossible to ascertain the reasons which compelled the judge to award interest from the date of filing suit and this leads us…

…to the inevitable conclusion that the learned judge wrongly exercised his discretion” We have in the present appeal, an analogous situation where we cannot ascertain the reasons which compelled the learned judge, without…

…I have been addressed by both counsel as to why I should or should not exercise my discretion in favour of the applicant.…

…In that regard I will exercise my discretion in favour of the applicant and order that the application be fixed for hearing before the full Court urgently. Costs in the application.…

…In our view the Chief Justice did not err in the exercise of his discretion in granting the application for review. We dismiss the appeal but make no order as to costs.…

…There is no specific ground of appeal against this but we allowed Mr Ngatia to address us on the matter as we felt that the judge had wrongly exercised his discretion by ordering the appellants to pay the Mayor’s costs.…