Search court decisions

…She argued that this fact should have exempted her from contributory negligence, and that the trial court’s failure to consider it led to an incorrect finding of liability. 8.…

…This brings the court to the second critical issue: whether there is evidence of contributory negligence on the part of the Appellant.…

…Finally, he reduced all these awards by 50% on the ground of contributory negligence by the deceased.…

…When the trial commenced the respondent’s advocate sought formal leave to amend the defence to incorporate a plea of contributory negligence on the part of the deceased.…

…DW1 testified stating how the accident occurred and the element of contributory negligence clearly comes out.…

…On whether the deceased is liable for contributory negligence. The law on contributory negligence is to apportion proximate cause and blameworthiness where appropriate. …

…negligence. d) That the learned magistrate erred in law and fact in finding that the deceased was guilty of contributory negligence against the weight of the evidence presented by the plaintiffs. 8.…

…The Court can only find a minor guilty of contributory negligence if some blame is demonstrated to attach to him or her.…

…I take the two chief questions in turn: (i) liability and the finding of contributory negligence; and (ii) the quantum of general damages and of loss of earning capacity. (i) Liability and contributory negligence 16.…

…Take next the reduction founded on the appellant's own contributory negligence.…

…In the alternative, the appellants urged the Court to attribute 40% contributory negligence to the deceased for allegedly failing to fasten her seat belt.…

…It did not necessarily foreclose proof of contributory negligence by another road user, but it could not be disregarded as being of no evidential value. 24.…

…The Appellant raised contributory negligence in her defence. I find no evidence presented by the Respondent as to how he could not himself avoid the accident.…

…Consequently, the defence of contributory negligence was not plausible.…

…The Appellant raised contributory negligence in her defence. I find no evidence presented by the Respondent as to how he could not himself avoid the accident.…

…Consequently, the defence of contributory negligence was not plausible.…

…While the respondents actively appeared and argued their case in the Lower Court, asserting contributory negligence and shifting blame within their pleadings, a distinction must be drawn between active legal arguments and…

…The mere assertion of contributory negligence within a written statement of defense or closing submissions does not transmute those claims into proved facts.…

…Although the Appellant had pleaded contributory negligence on the part of the Respondent, no witness was called to explain the Appellant's version of how the accident occurred.…

…It is therefore insufficient for the Appellant merely to deny liability and invite the court to infer contributory negligence without evidential support. 36.…

…The Kenyan courts have pronounced themselves on several occasions on the issue of contributory negligence of a child where courts have stated that a child of tender years cannot be guilty of contributory negligence unless…

…Therefore, this Tribunal cannot apportion contributory negligence on the minor. Uninsulated electric supply lines ought not to be so close to reach especially for a minor of a tender age of nine years. 27.…

…On whether the Respondent is liable for contributory negligence. The law on contributory negligence is to apportion proximate cause and blameworthiness where appropriate. …

…In De Frias v Rodney 1998 BDA LR 15 it was held as follows: “Contributory negligence required the foreseeability harm to oneself. …

…On whether the Respondent is liable for contributory negligence. The law on contributory negligence is to apportion proximate cause and blameworthiness where appropriate. …

…In De Frias v Rodney 1998 BDA LR 15 it was held as follows: “Contributory negligence required the foreseeability harm to oneself. …

…Thorne [1966] WLR 1387 (Lord Denning), it was said “A very young child cannot be guilty of contributory negligence. An older child may be. But it depends on the circumstances.…

…The assessment of contributory negligence on the part of the respondent, at 50%, was wholly erroneous, and the wrong principle was applied.…

…The trial court apportioned liability at 50:50% and awarded damages as follows:- General damages Kshs. 180,000/= Special damages Kshs. 2,350/= Total Kshs. 182,350/= Less 50% contributory negligence 4.…

…The appellant further said that the respondent failed to provide any evidence to support a claim of contributory negligence, as legally required. 7.…

…The Appellant’s case is that a child ought not be held liable for contributory negligence.…

…First, the claim for contributory negligence as pleaded by the Respondents was against the father and next friend and not the Appellant.…

…He urged this court to reassess contributory negligence and apportion liability in ratio 50:50.…

…The appellant alleges contributory negligence. Contributory negligence refers to the negligence of the claimant which contributed to or wholly caused the harm.…

…In attempting to explain negligence and contributory negligence the court in Mois Bridge Quaru Ltd =vs= Martin Omuge Edoan, Justice E.K.…

…The appellants non suited themselves by failing to plead contributory negligence. Having not filed a defence, the court could only deal with liability of the Respondent and not the contributory negligence of Appellant.…

…The parties entered into a consent on liability where the appellants were 80 per cent liable, and the respondents were to shoulder 20 per cent contributory negligence.…

…The respondents were awarded Kshs. 4,300,00.00 in general damages and Kshs. 263, 615.00 special damages before factoring in contributory negligence. 2.…