Skip to content
JudgmentPETER MUTINDA VS EVANS WAMBUA AND RAFIKI TRANS AFRICA CO LTD2 min read

PETER MUTINDA VS EVANS WAMBUA AND RAFIKI TRANS AFRICA CO LTD

High Court at Makueni High Court · · Matheka, Teresia Mumbua


RULING
1) The  application before  me is the notice  of  motion   dated  23/10/2023   seeking inter  alia,  stay  of  execution    of the  judgment   and decree   of  the  subordinate  court  Tawa SPMCC  112/2022  of  31/8/2023  pending  the hearing  and  determination  of the  appeal  herein.
2) The main  ground   for the application  is  that  the learned  trial  court  did not  consider  the appellant’s   evidence  on quantum  and  found     the   respondents  -  on liability   -  100 %  and quantum of  damages  Kshs.  200,000.
3) The  application  is  supported  by  the  affidavit   sworn  by Peter    Mutinda  -  the appellant/applicant  on  23/10/2023.
4) A replying  affidavit  opposing  the application  sworn  by  Evans   Wambua  -  1st     respondent,  sworn   on  27/11/2023  - on  the ground  that the application  does  not comply with  order  42  rule  6 (2) (b)  of  the Civil   Procedure  Code.
5) That   should  the court  consider   allowing the application, then  the  applicant  to  release  part of the funds  to the applicant,   and deposit  the  balance   in  a  joint  interest  earning   account -  otherwise   the  application ought  to be  dismissed.
6) Let  me  just  point  out -  that  this  ruling  has been  delayed   because  since  18/3/2023  when the    file  was  before  me  for  direction,  it  remained   for  mention  before  Deputy  Registrar   for compliance and came  back  on  14/11/2024   by which    time the  applicant    had  not  filed  their  submissions,  then I  proceeded   on leave  -  and  matter  was  mentioned   before  Deputy  Registrar   on  27/11/2024  when  date of  31/3/2025   was  fixed for  ruling.
7) Having considered the application – I checked CTs   for the submissions. I only found the   submissions of the respondents   dated 18/4/2024.  I did not find any submission by the applicant.
8) The only   issue on the appeal is quantum of damages.  The judgment   of the subordinate court shows how the trial court arrived   at   its   award.
9) In the  circumstances  -  I allow  the  application on the  following    conditions -   that   there  be  stay  of  execution  pending   the   hearing and determination of the appeal  herein.
10) That  the  applicant   do  pay  the respondents  the  sum  of  Kshs.  150,000   within   30 days, hereof.
11) The  balance   of the decretal   sum be  deposited   in a  joint   interest  earning  account  in the    names of  the    Advocates   within   30  days , hereof.
12) The Record of appeal   be filed and served within 30 days, hereof.
13) In default   -  the  application  will  stand  dismissed   with  costs,  the stay will  lapse accordingly.
Dated and signed and delivered virtually this 4th April 2025
Mumbua T Matheka
Judge
Odero holding brief for Mutua Makau for Respondent
N/A for applicant
Chrispol Court Assistant



    PETER MUTINDA VS EVANS WAMBUA AND RAFIKI TRANS AFRICA CO LTD PETER MUTINDA VS EVANS WAMBUA AND RAFIKI TRANS AFRICA CO LTD