Skip to content
JudgmentJUSTUS MUTUA NZUKI VS The Republic3 min read

JUSTUS MUTUA NZUKI VS The Republic

High Court at Makueni High Court · · Matheka, Teresia Mumbua


1.    The applicant was charged tried convicted and sentenced for 7 counts of causing death by dangerous driving contrary to section 46 of the Traffic act Cap 403 Laws of Kenya in Kilungu Principal Magistrate Case 670/2017. He was sentenced to pay fine of Kshs.100,000/= in default one year imprisonment on each of the 7 counts.
2.    He filed HCCRA E077/2021. It was dismissed vide the judgment of this court (Hon. Dulu J) on 19/10/2022.
3.    On 2/5/2023 he filed this application headed Notice of Petition
a.    That I appeal for the application of section 333(2) of the penal code.
b.    That  my   sentence  to  start from the 24th December,  2016   but  not  from 1st August, 2021. 
c.    That   was arrested on the 24th December, 2016 but not   from 1st August, 2021.
d.    That I wish   to be present in person for the hearing of this application. 
4.    It also contained a Petition of Sentence Review
1.    That   the sentence   was too harsh    on this case. 
2.    That I humbly pray for the application of section 333(2) of the penal code. 
3.    That  my sentence  to start  from   the  24th  December, 2016  but  not  from 1st  August, 2021
4.    That    I pray for the sentence to be reduced   to the time served. 
5.    That I wish   to be present in court on the hearing of this appeal application.
6.    That I pleaded    not guilty at trial.
7.    That I would be grateful of any other option which the hon.  Court would come up with. 
5.    And a Memorandum of Grounds of Appeal
1.    That   I  humbly   pray  that  my sentence should  start  from the date  of  arrest  according to section 333(2)  of  the CPC.
2.    That  my sentence   to start  from  the  24th  December, 2016  but not  from 1st August, 2021.
3.    That I pray for the sentence to be reduced to the time served.
4.    That I pray to be present in court on the hearing of this petition. 
5.    That  I  would  comply  with any other  option  to be  given  by this  Hon.  Court. 
6.    That   the sentence was imposed   when no plea of guilt was entered. 
6.     Supporting sworn   affidavit
1.     That, I  am    a Kenyan   male adult  citizen  and    of  sound mind  and the appellant in this  appeal  and hence competent   to swear  this  oath on my  behalf.
2.      That I am the accused person in the above mentioned criminal case number.
3.    That I am currently held at Makueni G.K Prison. 
4.    That my grounds of application are attached herein. 
5.    That I am a poor man and hence    pray to this Hon. court to allow me appeal as a pauper. 
6.    That all facts stated here are true to the best of my knowledge
7.    For submissions, he filed submissions he had filed in the HCC 77/2021.
8.    I have carefully considered the application and he only issue is whether the application has merit.
9.    The application combines an appeal, an application for review of sentence.
10.    Both these are overtaken by events because on 19/10/2022 this court pronounced itself,(Hon Dulu J)  and dismissed his appeal – thereby upholding both the conviction and the sentence.
11.    On the issue of the application of section 333(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code it is evident that the applicant was on bond throughout his trial, hence the provision of the law is not applicable to him.
12.    The application is dismissed.
Dated, signed and delivered virtually this 28th August 2024
Mumbua T Matheka
Judge
Ms. Mwanatumu
Ms.  Nyakibia for state
Applicant


    JUSTUS MUTUA NZUKI VS The Republic JUSTUS MUTUA NZUKI VS The Republic